Be a tiger moth

Exactly what we’ve been talking about this week at annual meeting: priorities + stakeholders + funding must be in alignment and change should happen. Post from the executive leader of Phoenix Bioinformatics, platform that now hosts resources like TAIR and Morphobank at a cost because they did not have funding to proceed. Edited to add BHL photo as tax!

https://www.linkedin.com/posts/josh-young-659b6710_the-unfortunate-reality-is-that-many-science-activity-7455628739100499969-h30n?utm_source=li_share&utm_content=feedcontent&utm_medium=g_mb_web&utm_campaign=copy

2 Likes

@ktrei That link didn’t work for me :frowning: but this seems to work:

1 Like

Thank you! Sorry about that, I’ll get this discourse thing yet :wink:

No worries, I’m pretty sure the problem is with LinkedIn not you!

1 Like

@ktrei The Phoenix example is interetsing because they have explicit tiers of membership based on limiting access to content, and manage that via IP addresses. This raises the issue of how to manage access (I suspect that single sign on might be the way to do that).

It also raises the issue of what would be free and what would cost money. That’s likely to be a tough conversation, but I wonder if a starting point might be:

  1. Scanned images of content (i.e., what most people see in the existing website) remian free to anyone, but OCR text, mark up of taxonomic names, full text search, etc. require a fee
  2. Members get all the chocholately goodness for their contributions, and can see page scans of all content. Chocholately goodness includes lots of metrics (web page views, citations, external site links) for that member
  3. Top tier members get chocolately goodness for all content
  4. Double plus gold pro star members get to ask for a feature to be added (money back if not delivered)
  5. In additon to membership model, subscription packages could be created, e.g. buy access to 1000 pages of marked up, annotated, image cleaned pages. This is similar to what AI tools are doing, pay per play. Another option is to offer “personal BHL”, that is, the ability to download an copy of part of BHL as a functioning, standalone app that includes images so you can have BHGl where ever you go (perhaps one time fee to download, pay small amount to update of more content becomes available).

This is all arm wavvy, but I think BHL needs to think about a model that maintains some degree of free access (because that’s the motivating vision), but generates supporting revenue from the added value BHL creates (and which costs time and money). If there is no prospect of a rich donor person or organisation, it is hard to see how BHL remains financially viable without generating income directly. At the same time, I think there should be at least one free tier, otherwise the notion of “open” goes away.

We should probably look at a range of other organisations, such as OpenAlex, which has open data and APIs, but rate limits APIs (rates can be increased by paying money). OpenAlex also refer to POSI which I had not seen before.

1 Like

And often the free access of most resources on Phoenix are not great, it’s mostly where resources go if they cannot figure out a way to be sustainable. And then it becomes like any other library database Illinois pays for but no longer has any actually ties to. I mostly liked the succinct way the director phrased the alignment in order for success.

BUT, I think the “freemium” idea is intriguing especially when we think about really high quality OCR or text mining potentially. The open access component to Illinois is arguably the main reason we are involved, but adding value and/or recouping costs are also important to consider.

(But of course, first modeling/building the new interface or platform, and keeping in line with funding as we build capacity)

@ktrei I worry about

“first modeling/building the new interface or platform”

To me all these things are linked. The funding model has implications for how you design the platform, and what features you prioritise. Same with content, a service oriented approach has implications for what content gets prioritised. Maybe I’m missing something, but I don’t see a clear strategy that connects the current funding situation, the state of the platform, content acquisition priorities, and user needs.

I agree they are all linked and I think that’s why it is important that we DO purposefully link them. I was just saying my ruminations aren’t very useful before the testing & planning.